Eastbourne garage housing plans rejected by councillors

3 Min Read


Listen to audio version below: Sponsored by Sussex Audiology Centre

PLANS to replace 11 garages with four homes in Eastbourne have been refused after councillors raised concerns about their impact on neighbouring residents.

Eastbourne Borough Council’s planning committee rejected the proposals for land behind West Cliff Mansion in St John’s Road on Tuesday, October 13, despite officers recommending approval.

The application, submitted by Derek Godfrey, sought permission to build four two-bedroom townhouses behind the 10-storey apartment building.

Councillors concluded the development would have an unacceptable effect on neighbouring homes, with concerns about its design, loss of light and the sense of enclosure it would create.

Cllr Jane Lamb (Con), who proposed refusal, said: “[There are] implications for both the people in West Cliff [Mansion] and in South Cliff Avenue for having what is rather a brutal-looking and uninspiring block of four houses. It is significant; it not only affects their outlook but also their amenity.”

She also raised concerns about the loss of parking and trees, while other committee members questioned the scheme’s design.

Following the discussion, officers suggested wording for a formal reason for refusal, which councillors agreed.

The grounds described the development as “cramped” and said it would “result in an overbearing and oppressive relationship with neighbouring dwellings and their associated amenity spaces.”

They also stated it would “give rise to an unacceptable loss of light, outlook and [create] a sense of enclosure for neighbouring occupiers.”

Officers had reached a different conclusion in their initial report. While acknowledging some limited effects on neighbours, they considered these insufficient to justify refusal.

Their report argued the scheme would provide additional housing, make efficient use of previously developed land and offer high-quality accommodation.

The application attracted 93 individual representations opposing the plans. Concerns included privacy, overshadowing, the loss of garages, harm to the area’s character, parking and pressure on infrastructure.

The council has previously refused a different developer’s proposals for a five-storey apartment building on the site.

Further details are available on Eastbourne Borough Council’s planning portal under application reference 250515.

Newsletter Sign Up
Find Cheapest Fuel in Eastbourne
Share This Article