EASTBOURNE councillors have reluctantly backed changes to the way planning applications are decided, amid warnings that new national rules will reduce the influence of elected representatives and local residents.
Listen to audio version below: Sponsored by Sussex Audiology Centre
Members of Eastbourne Borough Council’s planning committee expressed concerns about the impact on local democracy during a meeting on Tuesday, November 10, but were warned that refusing to implement the changes could leave the authority facing legal challenges and financial consequences.
The changes follow the introduction of the new National Scheme of Delegation, which came into effect on October 31 as a result of changes to national legislation.
The scheme introduces new rules governing which planning applications can be determined by elected councillors and which must be decided by planning officers without going before a committee.
Critics argue the changes undermine local democracy by removing certain powers that allow councillors to request that planning applications be considered by the committee, rather than being decided by officers.
Committee members were asked to recommend amendments to the council’s constitution to bring its planning procedures into line with the new national requirements.
However, before reaching a decision, councillors questioned what would happen if the authority refused to adopt the changes.
Responding, the committee’s legal advisor, Helen Monaghan, warned that continuing to operate under the existing arrangements could expose planning decisions to legal challenges.
She said: “If you didn’t accept this and we continued contrary to what national legislation says, then any approval or refusal of a planning permission application may then be subject to quashing by judicial review (JR).”
She added: “There are [also] financial risks of a JR being brought against decisions being made by a committee who are not lawfully making decisions, because it is contrary to the national legislation.
“There are reputational risks with regards to if you want investors into the town, because they are not confident in the system that you have because you have not approved this [in a full council vote].”
The legal position led to the adoption of the changes being repeatedly described during the meeting as a “fait accompli”, with councillors having little practical choice but to comply.
Despite their reservations, a majority of committee members ultimately agreed to recommend the constitutional changes to full council, but with reluctance.
However, some councillors opposed the recommendation, arguing that the new system would weaken the ability of elected representatives to speak on behalf of their communities.
Among them was Conservative councillor Jane Lamb, who strongly criticised the implications for local democracy.
She said: “This new system … is being handed down to us as a way of reducing local people’s input into what is being built in their town.
“It is an insult to the idea that you vote for people who are going to represent you, because they are going to find it very difficult to represent you and the complexity of the new system, no matter how many tiny safeguards you put in, makes it even more difficult.”
She added: “I have great respect for the head of planning and the chair of this committee, and they are in a dilemma also, but I do not feel at all like I can support, however reluctantly.”
The proposed constitutional changes will now go before the full council for consideration.

